Soaked in themes of infidelity, morality and the harsh realities of modern urbanism, Gehraiyaan, directed by Shakun Batra, is a wildly engrossing and occasionally disturbing (okay, maybe more than occasional) film that is as much a victory of the writing as it is of the internalized lived-in performances.
Shakun Batra's directorial curve has grown more exponentially than the surge in COVID cases in Europe in the last few months. Debuting with Ek Main Aur Ek Tu, which frankly was a passable romantic comedy, he upgraded to the terrific Kapoor & Sons, a film which dented the image of the typical cutesy Indian middle class family which Hindi films have portrayed for years before. The characters were flawed, they made seriously questionable decisions and they all kept secrets of their own, all of which were strategically and elegantly let out in an extremely engaging fashion. Despite all its merits, I still felt the film could have been crisper and more focused, especially in the first half. At a running time of two and a half hours, however, Gehraiyaan rarely feels long because Batra and his co-writers painstakingly build up the plot and imbue each frame with moody atmospherics, throwing in twist after twist to sustain the tension. The film is darker and more unsettling, even by Batra's own standards.
While his direction certainly cannot be faulted, the real hero of the film remains the script. Just when we begin to think that the film is essentially one character's story, the writers turn the spotlight onto another character, making this person now the "interim protagonist". Bolstered by a radiant ensemble, each and every actor gets a chance to shine. Rajat Kapoor is suitably sly; Ananya Pandey, although still raw, is nicely cast in a role which seems like her natural self for the most part. Deepika Padukone and Siddhant Chaturvedi do most of the emotional heavy lifting and they come off as utterly convincing. They bring the required depth to every scene, something which the film aimed to explore even through its title.
My only complaint with the film is a revelation about one of the 'interim protagonist's" relation with the parents in the last bits of the film. It felt force-fed into the story for the supposed purpose of tying up loose threads but it comes off as a tad tacky. This, however, is offset by the makers' decision to keep an open ending and let us mull over the consequences of that final encounter. It's probably a manifestation of Batra's inherent cynicism where he cannot let his characters and their lives stay happy for too long.
I am going with 4/5 stars for Gehraiyaan. While this may not be everyone's cup of tea, I highly recommend you to give it a shot, especially because films of this supreme quality and texture rarely knock on the doors of Hindi cinema.
